The first step is to draw equal sized vertical and horizontal axes of a graph. Mccabe iq enables you to deliver better, more secure, and more reliable software to your en dusers, and is known worldwide as the gold standard for the analysis, comprehension, testing, and reengineering of new software and legacy systems. The mccabethiele method is considered to be the simplest and perhaps most instructive method for the analysis of binary distillation. Yet some consider graphical techniques tools of the past, and as a result, the distillation column has become a black box and. This demonstration uses a stepbystep approach to calculate the number of stages for a specified distillation problem using the mccabendashthiele method. This application also highlights several maple concepts. Mccabethiele method of distillation design the mccabethiele method of distillation design is a graphical method of design that dates back to the early 20 th century. Mccabethiele diagram as we can see from the figures below 1, the separation factor affects the number of stages necessary to obtain a desired separation. Results can be scaled to actual reflux ratio, typically r 1. A saturated liquid feed q 1 was assumed, as the feed was heated to close to its bubble point. Thiele in an article titled graphical design of fractionating columns. A mccabethiele plot is a simplified tool to assist in understanding distillation. How to construct mccabe thiele diagram for lle and is.
In this video we show how to use microsoft excel to draw the mccabe thiele diagram including the 45 line, top section line, qline and bottom section. This application calculates the required number of theoretical stages for a set of specified operating parameters via the mccabe thiele method. Now iii mccabethiele model the mccabethiele method is the simplest and perhaps most instructive method for the analysis of binary theoretical tray or equilibrium stage is. Mccabethiele graphical method example part 1 youtube. Simulation of multistage countercurrent liquidliquid.
Mccabethiele vaxasoftware started by haih5, apr 16 2010 12. Mccabe thiele software mccabe thiele calculator from eqcomp can draw temperature concentration diagram txy plot and concentration diagram xy plot for any binary mixture of nonpolar hydrocarbons at near atmospheric and elevated pressures. The mccabethiele graphical solution method for binary distillation is used to determine the number of equilibrium stages needed to achieve a specified separation in a. The material balance is represented as the operation lines on the xy diagram according to the mccabe thiele method. Mccabethiele method for an ideal binary mixture file exchange. The separation of a binary waterethanol solution via a. Uses the mccabethiele graphical method to determine the number of equilibrium stages in a distillation column. The material balance is represented as the operation lines on the xy diagram according to the mccabethiele method. Binary distillation using mccabe thiele diagram calculates total number of stages, feed point required to separate a binary mixture with given relative volatility, reflux ratio, feed, bottom, distillate mol. Ponchansavarit method requires enthalpyconcentration.
We draw the mccabe and thiele diagram and get the number of theoretical plates equal to 9. Plot the equilibrium isotherm with organic concentration on the y axis and aqueous on the x axis. Aspen tutorial chemical engineering and materials science. The simple mccabethiele method for designing binary distillation systems version. This excel spreadsheet for mccabethiele method is awesome. Both mccabethiele and ponchonsavarit methods require concentration diagrams xy plot and temperatureconcentration diagrams txy plot at the operating pressure of the distillation column. I think this spreadsheet is stunningly helpful for understanding the mccabethiele method for the analysis of binary distillation. The distillate, feed and bottom mole fractions are 0.
This forum is not meant for asking members about stolen intellectual property. The mccabe thiele method was published 90 years ago by warren l. For instance, a user should have some idea of the column behavior before attempting to use aspen. This disambiguation page lists articles associated with the title mccabe. Binary distillation with the mccabethiele method application center. Mccabe thiele plates calculator free software downloads. It uses the fact that the composition at each theoretical tray or equilibrium stage is completely determined by the mole fraction of one of the two components and is based on the assumption of constant molar overflow which requires that. A plot of the equilibrium curve of a binary mixturewhich displays the mole fraction of a chemical mixture in the liquid phase that is in an equilibrium condition with that chemical mixture in the vapor phaseis the basis of the graphical. Then we step off the specified number of equilibrium contacts on each operating line starting at x d to find the x w value corresponding to. Mccabethiele diagram for a nonideal binary system to facilitate classroom.
I think this spreadsheet is stunningly helpful for understanding the mccabe thiele method for the analysis of binary distillation. Mccabe thiele method for distillation of binary mixtures. The mccabethiele method was published 90 years ago by warren l. Mccabe software solutions to guide you through the. Plotting mccabethiele diagrams in microsoft excel for nonideal systems. Mccabe thiele plot to find minimum number of trays. The mccabe thiele method is considered to be the simplest and perhaps most instructive method for the analysis of binary distillation. Mccabe thiele method is a procedure followed in finding number of equilibrium trays of a binary distillation column. Sep 25, 2019 the mccabethiele diagram is a graphical design procedure used to calculate a distillation system and its operating parameters. The mccabethiele visual approach provides a powerful way to attain this judgment and competency. It uses the fact that the composition at each theoretical tray is completely determined by the mole fraction of one of the two components and is based on the assumption of constant molar overflow which requires that. Mccabe iq developers edition is an interactive, visual environment for managing software quality through advanced static analysis, providing a comprehensive solution to the challenges that face quality assurance and development teams.
So im trying to separate butanol and water using a distillation column. Ponchansavarit method requires enthalpyconcentration diagram hxy plot in addition to these two diagrams. Mccabethiele method for an ideal binary mixture file. Experienced process engineers often use mccabe thiele diagrams to understand or help debug simulation results 3. How can i draw an operating line and a mccabe thiele diagram.
When used with the mccabe thiele method, which is said to be the simplest and perhaps most instructive method for the analysis of binary distillation, the combination is formidable. Although modern process simulation packages such as aspen plus or proii can quickly and efficiently perform distillation column calculations, they often confuse students who are just beginning to learn distillation basics, leading to questions such as, why cant the reflux ratio be smaller than the minimum reflux. A binary distillation column is used to separate a binary hydrocarbon mixture based on the difference in volatilities of the two hydrocarbon compounds forming the hydrocarbon mixture. Mccabe iq uses advanced software metrics to identify, objectively measure, and report on the complexity. Distillation software free download distillation top 4. The mccabethiele method of distillation design is a graphical method of design that dates back to the early 20 th century. Visualizing the mccabethiele diagram reactions and. Jul 25, 2007 the feed is a two phase mixture with a feed quality is equal to 0. The effect of the separation factor alpha on a separation process as seen in the. Mccabethiele method gui for binary column distillation. Binary distillation using mccabe thiele diagram calculates total number of stages, feed point required to separate a binary mixture with given relative.
The mccabe thiele visual approach provides a powerful way to attain this judgment and competency. Aug 15, 2010 my first attempt at making a mccabethiele program. The mccabethiele method allows full control over reboiler duty, and it is not uncommon to first solve a problem assuming minimum reflux ratio. Or if there are any excel spreadsheet that linked to aspen via macro can dr mccabe thiele diagrams in aspen 2006. The feed is a two phase mixture with a feed quality is equal to 0. The program computes the number of equilibrium stages for a binary ideal. However, teachers know that drawing an accurate mccabethiele diagram, especially freehand, is quite difficult and rather timeconsuming. We definitely mind in telling you because this forum neither deals or supports any pirated software or engineering literature. The spreadsheet also automatically draw the traditional mccabe thiele plot. Computes number of plates, minimum reflux ratio, optimum feedplate, product recovery and flow rates. How to construct mccabe thiele diagram for lle and is there. Once the equilibrium curve is obtained, operating lines that identify the mass balance relationship between the liquid and vapor phases must be plotted. It is used as an introductory method to teach the design of distillation and is still in use today by engineers who design distillation columns. Novel representation of vapourliquid equilibrium curves.
Mccabethiele diagrams are helpful for teaching distillation to students in mass transfer or unit operations class. Simulation of multistage countercurrent liquidliquid extraction annasaheb warade, ravindra gaikwad, rajiv sapkal, and vilas sapkal 82 modified mccabe thiele method the separation achieved for a given number of ideal stages in a counter flow cascade can be determined by using a triangular diagram and special graphical techniques but a. These lines are derived by writing global and partial material balances around different sections of the column. You can manipulate some of the data and see the immediate graphical changes, which kinda puts the method into perspective a bit more clearly. The spreadsheet also automatically draw the traditional mccabethiele plot. Mccabe thiele plot to find minimum number of trays started by. Aspen is a process simulation software package widely used in industry today. Given a process design and an appropriate selection of thermodynamic models, aspen uses mathematical models to predict the performance of the process. The development of computers brought an increase in the number of software programs with a great potential to assist in the task of teaching engineering. This information could come from an approximate method, such as the mccabe thiele approach, general modeling of the txy behavior, or residue curve maps. Educational software tools statistics titration curve unit converter. Mcth number of theoretical plates by mccabethiele method for distillation towers of binary mixtures interactive changes using mccabethiele diagram full report printing vapor equilibrium using relative volatility or table of data easy and fast to use. Binary distillation with the mccabethiele method binary fractional distillation is a means of separating two liquid components via a distillation column which contains a number of trays, or stages. The mccabethiele diagram is a graphical design procedure used to calculate a distillation system and its operating parameters.
The precise control over the appearance of a plot for presenting engineering information. Construct a mccabethiele diagram for distillation wolfram. Aspen cannot tell you how many stages to use for a given separation. This article describes how to apply the mccabethiele method. We draw the mccabe and thiele diagram and get the number of theoretical plates. The temperature concentration diagram txy plot and concentration diagram xy plot can be used in mccabe thiele. The mccabethiele graphical solution method for binary distillation is used to determine the number of equilibrium stages needed to achieve a specified separation in a distillation column.
This can be seen in the different mccabethiele diagrams, which constitute of the operating line solid line and an equilibrium line dotted line. The first representation will plot the aspen plusand the proposed graphical method compositions on a mccabe thiele diagram to validate the behaviour of the of the components are correctly predicted by the novel method for representing the contours of vle. Software applications based on rigorous calculations do not explain how distillation really works and how the numerous process variables interact to yield a distilla tion column that is energy ef fi cient, stable, and produces products with the. Before starting the construction and use of a mccabe thiele diagram for the distillation of a binary feed, the vaporliquid equilibrium vle data must be obtained for the lowerboiling component of the feed. Jul 12, 2005 binary distillation with the mccabe thiele method binary fractional distillation is a means of separating two liquid components via a distillation column which contains a number of trays, or stages. A mccabethiele diagram for the absorption operation from separation process engineering by wankat, 2007 note that the operating line in the mccabethiele diagram for. The relationship between x d and x w can now be found from a stagebystage calculation using a mccabethiele analysis.
Plotting mccabethiele diagrams in microsoft excel for. Mccabethiele plots provide a simple, graphical tool for the analysis of binary. In the excel program, look at the tabs installed at the top of the ribbon to see if. Mar 12, 2012 in this video we show how to use microsoft excel to draw the mccabe thiele diagram including the 45 line, top section line, qline and bottom section line. Mccabe thiele plot to find minimum number of trays posted in student. A mccabe thiele diagram can be used for lle with a ternary system two solvents, one solute. It is desired to produce a distillate containing 0.
This is a classic chemical engineering diagram and shows the number of theoretical stages, the position and slope of the qline, and the relative volatility curve, and the purity of the top and bottom products. An example of the mccabethiele diagram for absorption is illustrated in figure 8. Mccabethiele vaxasoftware industrial professionals. It was found the exact composition of the bottom molar fraction, the effect of reflux ratio on the distillation molar. A representative mccabethiele plot of these calculations is shown in figure 1. This demonstration presents the mccabe and thiele graphical method, which is applicable to binary mixtures. The last step is to select a binary mixture from the given by the software. Experienced process engineers often use mccabethiele diagrams to understand or help debug simulation results 3. It is a method for calculating the number of theoretical trays required for the distillation of a binary mixture. Binary distillation using mccabe thiele diagram calculates total number of stages, feed point required to separate a binary mixture with given relative volatility, reflux ratio, feed, bottom, distillate mol fraction.
First, the rectifying and stripping operating lines are plotted using a reflux ratio equal to 1. Mccabethiele method gui for binary column distillation file. Binary distillation with mccabethiele method excel. Novel representation of vapourliquid equilibrium curves for. Thus, this paper details a method for generating a mccabethiele diagram using microsoft excel. The usual assumption is the extract and raffinate phase flow rates are constant, which is reasonable. Hi, i have calculated the number of theoretical stages for a distillation column that fractionate 3000kgh of an acetonebenzene solution containing 0. This can be seen in the different mccabe thiele diagrams, which constitute of the operating line solid line and an equilibrium line dotted line. Plotting mccabethiele diagrams in microsoft excel for non.
The effect of reflux ratio on tray distillation efficiency. The mccabe thiele graphical solution method for binary distillation is used to determine the number of equilibrium stages needed to achieve a specified separation in a distillation column. The relationship between x d and x w can now be found from a stagebystage calculation using a mccabe thiele analysis. Stepping off stages course description learncheme features faculty prepared engineering education resources for students and instructors produced by the department of chemical and biological engineering at the university of colorado boulder and funded by the national science foundation, shell, and the engineering excellence fund. It plots the classic mccabe thiele diagram and evaluates the minimum and actual reflux ratio, and the thermodynamic state of the feed. It plots the classic mccabethiele diagram and evaluates the minimum and actual reflux ratio, and the thermodynamic state of the feed. The mccabethiele method is based on the assumption of constant molar overflow which requires that. Mccabe thiele diagram as we can see from the figures below 1, the separation factor affects the number of stages necessary to obtain a desired separation. Mccabe thiele diagram calculates total number of stages, feed point required in a distillation column to separate a binary mixture with given relative volatility. For these computations, the constant molar overflow assumption on the vapor and liquid rates in each section was applied. It is a method for calculating the number of theoretical trays. When used with the mccabethiele method, which is said to be the simplest and perhaps most instructive method for the analysis of binary distillation, the combination is formidable.
10 1491 357 419 660 714 62 1147 267 842 817 173 829 1026 837 904 157 141 248 1498 795 99 1378 297 1524 782 1136 1154 461 510 1547 1198 1223 289 482 1021 364 1454 828 419